Donna Andrews: The Nightingale Before Christmas

The year before last’s entry in Donna Andrews’s Meg Langslow series: An uninhabited  Caerphilly house has been turned into a show house for the local interior designers’ pre-Christmas competition, which Meg has agreed to organize (her own mother being one of the contestants, and Meg’s involvement as an organizer having been the price for their own house not to be used as the scene of competition) — as a result of which Meg is having to constantly mediate between the contestants, who keep going at each others’ throats hammer and tongs and are, as a whole, more unruly than a bag of wriggling kittens.  It doesn’t particularly help, either, that there’s a student hanging around the place doing research for an article on the competition that she’s writing for the local university newspaper, that moreover, packages containing the contestants’ orders of items needed in their decorative arrangements keep disappearing, and that at last someone even takes to vandalizing the house and some of the half-arranged rooms, with merely a few days to go to Christmas (and to the advent of the judges).  When the most unpopular of the contestants — whom the others also hold responsible for the disappearance of their packages and for the vandalization of their rooms — is found murdered, there doesn’t seem a shortage of suspects … except that every single one of the other designers seems to have a credible alibi.

 A more than solid, tremendously enjoyable entry in the series … having read Duck the Halls just before Christmas last year, I’m seriously tempted to hunt down all of Andrews’s holiday books and read them, one at a time, before Christmas each year!  She truly has a knack for combining a hilarious storyline with fully-rounded characters (however unusual), a homely and comfortably-feeling small-town setting and a lot of warmth, humor, and common sense.  Highly recommended!

9 thoughts on “Donna Andrews: The Nightingale Before Christmas

  1. Murder by Death says:

    This is exactly what I do – although the last few years she’s had new ones out so I haven’t had to rely on re-reading the older ones – although I do still read Duck the Halls every year, because it’s my favorite and gives me best sense of Christmas Spirit (and last year’s Owl be Home for Christmas is good too for xmas spirit).


    • ThemisAthena says:

      I hadn’t yet read “Six Geese A’Slaying” when I wrote this review (it’s not a new one; I’m in the process of updating / extracting reviews contained in summary blog posts as reviews of their own), but yes, I agree on “Duck the Halls” especially — that one, “The Nightingale Before Christmas” and “Six Geese …” are my favorite Christmas books by her. Though I did like last year’s as well — I particularly like that there and in “Six Geese …” she made a deliberate point of including other holiday traditions.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Murder by Death says:

    I suspect there’s going to be a lot of posts like these that I comment on – ones that aren’t new, but newly brought over – I’ve already done it once or twice on BT’s site too. 😀

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.